Tired of Me Talking About Icons Yet?

Well, you can't get away just yet -- I need an opinion on something. I'm trying to find a good "With this candle, I will light your way in darkness" icon, and I've got two choices -- one made by somebody else (theshadowlight on LJ) and one made by me. Which one do you think works better?

theshadowlight

mine

Tell me what you think! Or that I have 100 icons and can have two if I really want, but I don't want to waste slots even with that